• Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Science of Money
Science of Money

How eating a product today shapes which brand you buy tomorrow

by Eric W. Dolan
November 16, 2026
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Grocery shopping involves navigating a steady stream of small uncertainties. Shoppers regularly weigh the risk of paying a premium against the worry that a new food item might not satisfy their needs. When shoppers feel unsure, they often rely on personal experience to guide their choices.

A new study published in the International Journal of Research in Marketing investigates how recent experiences of eating or drinking a product shape what shoppers put in their carts. The research reveals that the act of consuming a brand plays a distinct role in future purchases. This effect exists entirely separate from the act of simply having bought the item in the past.

Separating purchase from consumption

Marketing researchers have long recognized that a shopper’s purchase history is a strong predictor of what they will buy today. If a person regularly buys a specific brand of cereal, they have a high probability of buying it again.

Science of Money
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter for the latest insights.

Kathleen Cleeren of KU Leuven and her colleagues noticed a missing piece in this behavioral puzzle. Purchasing a product and consuming it are two different events that often happen days or weeks apart. Purchasing tends to focus a consumer’s attention on external attributes like price, packaging size, or in-store promotions.

Consuming the product, on the other hand, activates the senses. Experiencing taste, smell, and texture creates vivid and easily retrievable memories. The research team set out to determine if these fresh consumption memories influence brand choice independently of a shopper’s prior purchasing habits.

ADVERTISEMENT

They also wanted to understand how this relationship changes when shoppers face different levels of uncertainty. Uncertainty in a grocery store typically falls into two categories. Financial uncertainty relates to the worry of wasting money on an item that is not worth the price, while performance uncertainty is the doubt a consumer feels regarding the actual quality or taste of the item.

Tracking pantries and purchases

To answer these questions, the researchers needed data that tracked both what people bought and what they actually ate at home. They utilized a dataset from the United Kingdom containing behavior records for 3,770 households over a three-year period. This data combined household scanner records, which logged everyday grocery purchases, with home consumption diaries.

In these diaries, participants recorded the specific products they ate or drank during multiple two-week observation windows. The team analyzed purchases across 178 food and beverage categories, focusing on the top five brands in each product group. To measure recent brand consumption, they tracked whether a household had consumed a specific brand within the seven days prior to a shopping trip.

The statistical model factored in how memories decay over those seven days, operating on the premise that a consumption event yesterday is easier to recall than one a week ago. They then compared this consumption data against the household’s actual brand choices at the store.

The analysis accounted for established purchasing habits, such as baseline brand loyalty and the time elapsed since the last store visit. The researchers also isolated the effect of consumption by accounting for stockpiling behavior. The model controlled for inventory depletion, confirming that the memory of consumption itself drove the purchase beyond the basic need to simply restock an empty pantry.

The role of uncertainty

The analysis showed that recent brand consumption is linked to a significant increase in the likelihood of a shopper choosing that same brand again. This increase occurred even when controlling for the shopper’s established purchasing habits. The researchers found that consuming a brand provides a separate stream of internal information that shoppers actively rely on to make decisions.

The researchers also found that shoppers lean on these fresh consumption memories more heavily when they face uncertain situations. When testing the data against different types of uncertainty, they found that financial concerns played a dominant role. Higher-priced brands carry a larger financial risk, which amplifies the buyer’s need for reliable information.

The data showed that recent consumption had a stronger positive influence on the choice to buy a high-priced brand compared to a low-priced brand. Similarly, the strictness of a household’s grocery budget influenced how much shoppers relied on their recent eating experiences. Households managing strict budgets face higher stakes if a product fails to meet expectations or results in food waste.

For these budget-constrained shoppers, recent consumption was associated with a stronger pull toward a familiar brand. The vivid memory of eating the product requires less cognitive effort to retrieve than analyzing in-store alternatives, providing a reliable anchor for shoppers who are already mentally taxed by budget constraints.

Conversely, shoppers who had extensive past experience buying a specific brand relied less on recent consumption. The researchers interpret this as a sign that experienced buyers already have enough knowledge about the brand’s quality. This accumulated knowledge reduces their need to pull new information from recent memory when standing in the aisle.

From pantry to checkout

The findings offer practical takeaways for retail and brand managers. The research highlights that getting a product into a customer’s pantry is only part of the equation. Because actual consumption drives subsequent purchases, companies can benefit from strategies that encourage people to quickly use the products they buy.

Providing recipes, usage tips, or paired ingredients can help ensure products are consumed rather than left to expire in the back of a cabinet. Retailers can also use in-store sampling as a tool to bridge the gap between consumption and purchase in the same physical space. The authors argue that sampling is particularly useful for higher-priced items.

Shoppers on strict budgets or those eyeing premium brands often hesitate due to financial uncertainty. A free sample provides immediate sensory information that can override that hesitation. The fresh memory of the taste helps offset the perceived risk of the price tag.

The researchers note a limitation in their data, as the diaries recorded whether a consumption event occurred but not the specific portion size. They point out that consuming very large quantities of a product could potentially lead to a temporary satiety effect. This physical fullness might temporarily reduce a shopper’s immediate desire to restock the item.

Share133Tweet83Send

Related Posts

Psychology of Selling and Marketing

The psychology of buying clothes you haven’t seen

November 15, 2026
AI in Business

The hidden social cost of cashierless stores

November 14, 2026
Neuroeconomics

Can brain scans help retailers predict grocery sales?

November 12, 2026
Psychology of Selling and Marketing

Why combining four small coupons feels better than getting one big discount

November 11, 2026

Science of Money is part of the PsyPost Media Inc. network.

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

Follow us

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer