• Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
Science of Money
Science of Money

How trade policy uncertainty drives corporate greenwashing

by Eric W. Dolan
November 19, 2026
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Global supply chains face regular disruptions as tariffs change, international trade rules shift, and geopolitical relations evolve. At the same time, companies face mounting pressure from regulators, investors, and the public to reduce their carbon footprints and adopt sustainable business practices.

These dual pressures force business leaders to navigate a difficult balance. They must manage the financial risks associated with unpredictable trade environments while fulfilling expectations for environmental responsibility.

A recent study published in Applied Economics investigates how these macroeconomic shocks influence corporate environmental strategies. A research team led by Huangying Gu at Nanjing University in China set out to determine whether trade policy uncertainty influences a company’s likelihood of engaging in greenwashing.

Science of Money
Sign up for our free weekly newsletter for the latest insights.

Greenwashing occurs when a company’s claims about its environmental practices exceed its actual environmental performance. The researchers found that higher levels of trade policy uncertainty are linked to an increase in corporate greenwashing, as companies turn to low-cost symbolic disclosures to manage external expectations during periods of economic instability.

Measuring the Gap Between Claims and Actions

To investigate this relationship, the researchers analyzed data from Chinese A-share publicly listed companies between 2015 and 2023. The final sample included nearly 9,000 annual company observations across various industries.

ADVERTISEMENT

The researchers needed a reliable way to measure greenwashing. They defined it as the gap between what a company reports about its Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives and its verified ESG outcomes.

To measure the claims, they used Bloomberg ESG disclosure scores, which track the scope and volume of information a company releases to the public. To measure actual performance, they used the Huazheng ESG rating, a metric tailored to the Chinese market that tracks concrete outcomes like regulatory penalties and verifiable sustainability actions.

A large positive gap between a company’s disclosure score and its performance score indicated a higher degree of greenwashing. The researchers also measured trade policy uncertainty at the individual firm level. They used text analysis software to scan company annual reports for specific keywords related to trade uncertainty, calculating how frequently these terms appeared in the executives’ narrative disclosures.

The Links Between Uncertainty and Greenwashing

The analysis revealed that companies facing higher trade policy uncertainty engaged more heavily in greenwashing. The researchers identified two primary sequences of events that help explain this trend.

The first involves risk avoidance. Developing new green technologies or overhauling supply chains requires significant, long-term financial investments. When trade policies fluctuate frequently, executives perceive higher risks and tend to adopt conservative financial strategies.

The study showed that trade uncertainty was linked to reduced risk-taking, reflected in lower volatility in a company’s return on assets, as management adopted more conservative strategies and postponed expensive environmental projects. Because the pressure to appear environmentally responsible remains constant, companies substitute actual investments with inexpensive public relations efforts, relying on selective disclosures to maintain a green reputation.

The second sequence involves resource constraints. Substantive green innovation requires stable funding. The researchers found that trade uncertainty restricts cash flow and tightens general corporate budgets, which leads to a measurable drop in green innovation.

The researchers tracked this drop by counting the number of independent green invention patents applied for by the companies. As funding for actual environmental research and development dried up during periods of trade uncertainty, companies were left with fewer avenues for genuine environmental improvement, increasing their reliance on superficial sustainability reports.

Who is Most Affected?

The study found that the link between trade policy uncertainty and greenwashing was not uniform across all companies. The effect was distinctly stronger for businesses that relied heavily on international markets, as measured by the ratio of their overseas revenue to total revenue.

Financial health also played a significant role. Companies with tight financial constraints exhibited a much stronger tendency to greenwash when faced with trade uncertainty. Firms with ample capital were better positioned to absorb macroeconomic shocks without abandoning their environmental commitments.

The local regulatory environment factored into the results as well. The researchers observed that companies operating in provinces with weaker environmental oversight were more likely to greenwash. In regions where authorities had recently conducted strict ecological inspections, the link between trade uncertainty and greenwashing disappeared entirely.

Public transparency provided another buffer. Companies with lower levels of information transparency, measured by the number of independent analyst reports covering the firm, were more likely to engage in greenwashing. The researchers argue that a lack of external oversight creates an environment where misleading environmental claims are less likely to be detected.

Subsidies and Artificial Intelligence

The researchers explored external and internal factors that might disrupt the cycle of uncertainty and greenwashing. They found that government subsidies can serve as an effective external buffer.

By providing a stable source of funding, subsidies help alleviate the cash flow pressures caused by volatile trade policies. This allows companies to pursue substantive environmental projects rather than resorting to low-cost symbolic actions.

However, the researchers noted that the benefit of government subsidies has a limit. Their calculations showed that subsidies were most effective at curbing greenwashing when they accounted for about 3.5 percent of a company’s operating revenue. Beyond that optimal range, additional subsidy funding did not yield further reductions in greenwashing.

Internally, the application of artificial intelligence technologies also mitigated the greenwashing effect. The researchers measured AI adoption by tracking the number of AI-related utility model patents a company obtained.

Firms with stronger AI capabilities were less likely to greenwash in response to trade uncertainty. The researchers interpret this as a result of AI systems improving internal data transparency. When environmental metrics like energy consumption and emissions are tracked continuously via automated systems, executives have less room to selectively edit or embellish the company’s environmental record.

The authors argue that relying on symbolic environmental strategies to navigate economic shocks is a fragile long-term approach. As ESG regulations grow stricter and data-tracking technologies advance, the likelihood that greenwashing will be detected and penalized will increase.

Share133Tweet83Send

Related Posts

Psychology of Selling and Marketing

New study reveals what actually predicts livestream shopping sales

November 18, 2026
Psychology of Selling and Marketing

How eating a product today shapes which brand you buy tomorrow

November 16, 2026
Psychology of Selling and Marketing

The psychology of buying clothes you haven’t seen

November 15, 2026
AI in Business

The hidden social cost of cashierless stores

November 14, 2026

Science of Money is part of the PsyPost Media Inc. network.

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

Follow us

  • Home
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer